1995 Season
A Shayna Maidel by Barbara Lebow
The Former One-on-One Basketball Champion and The 75th: Two plays by Israel Horovitz

1996 Season
The World of Sholom Aleichem  by Arnold Perl (staged reading)
The Value of Names by Jeffrey Sweet
A Body of Water by Jenna Zark

1997 Season
Jest A Second by James Sherman
Old Wicked Songs by Jon Marans

1998 Season
Dividends by Gary Richards
Old Wicked Songs by Jon Marans

1999 Season
Sight Unseen by Donald Margulies
Mizlansky/Zilinsky or “schmucks” by Jon Robin Baitz

2000 Season
The Chosen adapted by Aaron Posner & Chaim Potok
Never the Sinner by John Logan
The Magic Dreidels by Jenna Zark - MJTC Commission/World Premiere

2001 Season
Punch Me in the Stomach by Deb Filler & Alison Summers
The Substance of Fire by Jon Robin Baitz
The Magic Dreidels by Jenna Zark - MJTC Commission

2002 Repertory
Rose by Martin Sherman
The God of Isaac by James Sherman

2002-2003 Season
Talley’s Folly by Landford Wilson
The Magic Dreidels by Jenna Zark - MJTC Commission
And Then They Came for Me by James Still
Rose by Martin Sherman

2003-2004 Season
The King of the Kosher Grocers by Joe Minjares
The Magic Dreidels by Jenna Zark - MJTC Commission
Refugees by Stephanie Satie
Tommy J. and Sally by Mark Medoff

2004-2005 Season
Lovers & Traitors: The Killing of the Rosenbergs by Elissa Mautner - World Premiere
Hanukkah Lights in the Big Sky by Buffy Sedlachek - MJTC Commission/World Premiere
Family Secrets by Sherry Glaser
Miklat by Joshua Ford

2005-2006 Season
Shadow of the Valley by Lewis K. Schrager - World Premiere
Hanukkah Lights in the Big Sky by Buffy Sedlachek - MJTC Commission
Boychik by Richard Krevolin
The Twilight of the Golds by Jonathan Tolins

2006-2007 Season
The Action Against Sol Schumann by Jeffrey Sweet
The Odd Potato - Book & lyrics by Eileen B. Sherman, music by Gail C. Bluestone
Woman Before a Glass by Lanie Robertson
Modern Orthodox by Daniel Goldfarb

2007-2008 Season
Cherry Docs by David Gow
The Magic Dreidels by Jenna Zark - MJTC Commission
Parade - Music & lyrics by Jason Robert Brown, book by Alfred Uhry
The Triangle Factory Fire Project by Christopher Piehler in collaboration with Scot Alan Evans

2008-2009 Season
Chaim’s Love Song by Marvin Chernoff
Hershel and the Hanukkah Goblins by Shari Aronson
Chutzpah à go-go by David Gale & Randy Vancourt
2.5 Minute Ride by Lisa Kron

2009-2010 Season
Moonlight and Magnolias by Ron Hutchinson
Hershel and the Hanukkah Goblins by Shari Aronson
A Report on the Banality of Love by Mario Diament
Women’s Minyan by Naomi Ragen

2010-2011 Season
My Name is Asher Lev by Aaron Posner
Hershel and the Hanukkah Goblins by Shari Aronson
Goats by Alan Berks
The Gospel According to Jerry by Richard Krevolin & Irwin Kula - World Premiere

2011-2012 Season
Our Class by Tadeusz Slobodzianek; English version by Ryan Craig
The Magic Dreidels by Jenna Zark - MJTC Commission
My Mother’s Lesbian Jewish Wiccan Wedding by David Hein & Irene Carl Sankoff
The Last Word… by Oren Safdie

2012-2013 Season
My Mother’s Lesbian Jewish Wiccan Wedding by David Hein & Irene Carl Sankoff
Photograph 51 by Anna Ziegler
Hanukkah Lights in the Big Sky by Buffy Sedlachek - MJTC Commission
Compulsion or the House Behind by Rinne Groff
Handle With Care by Jason Odell Williams

2013-2014 Season
Rachel Calof adapted from the memoir by Ken LaZebnik; music and lyrics by Leslie Steinweiss
A Strange and Separate People by Jon Marans
The Magic Dreidels by Jenna Zark - MJTC Commission
The Last Five Years music and lyrics by Jason Robert Brown
The History of Invulnerability by David Bar Katz

2014-2015 Season
Rose by Martin Sherman
New Jerusalem, The Interrogation of Baruch De Spinoza at Talmud Torah Congregation:
Amsterdam, July 27, 1656 by David Ives
The Chanukah Guest by Jenna Zark - World Premiere
Stars of David, Conceived by Aaron Harnick and Abigail Pogrebin
Jericho by Jack Canfora

2015-2016 Season
Becoming Dr. Ruth by Mark St. Germain
The Twenty-Seventh Man by Nathan Englander
The Chanukah Guest by Jenna Zark - MJTC Commission
The Tale of the Allergist's Wife by Charles Busch
Bad Jews by Joshua Harmon

2016-2017 Season
DAI (enough) by Iris Bahr
Aunt Raini by Tom Smith
The Magic Dreidels by Jenna Zark
The Whipping Man by Matthew Lopez
We Are the Levinsons by Wendy Kout - World Premiere

2017-2018 Season
Via Dolorosa by David Hare
Church & State by Jason Odell Williams
Hershel and the Hanukkah Goblins by Shari Aronson
Collected Stories by Donald Margulies
Natasha and the Coat by Deborah Stein - World Premiere

2018-2019 Season
What I Thought I Knew by Alice Eve Cohen
The Last Schwartz by Deborah Zoe Laufer
The Chanukah Guest by Jenna Zark
Actually by Anna Ziegler
Shul by Sheldon Wolf - World Premiere